Crypto cost basis: Canada ACB vs US FIFO and specific ID
Understand Canadian average cost and US unit identification, wallet records and the temporary broker relief through 2026. A calculation tool, not tax advice.
Sources checked November 15, 2026. Canadian inclusion figures below refer to the 2025 tax year; US lot-identification notes cover 2025–2026.
Explore the free comparisonCanada: average the cost of identical units
The CRA describes a crypto-asset's ACB as usually its weighted average cost. Its identical-property guidance explains recalculating average cost when you buy more of the same property.[1][2]
For the Canadian calculation, collect the acquisition history needed to establish that average. A balance without its cost history does not establish ACB.
United States: identify the units in the wallet or account
IRS FAQs 82–87 describe identifying units and their holding periods within the relevant wallet/account. If adequate specific identification is missing, the default takes the earliest acquired units held there, regardless of when they entered that wallet.[3]
For an unhosted wallet, FAQ 82 requires identification by the disposal time and records that substantiate removal of those units. Selecting a label in tax software does not, by itself, establish those records.[3]
Broker identification has temporary relief through 2026
Notice 2026-20 extends relief for eligible broker-held units through December 31, 2026. Under its conditions, taxpayers can identify units in their books by the transaction time, or record a sufficiently detailed standing order before the transactions.[4]
The relief does not apply to unhosted units or change broker information-reporting rules. Your records and the broker's acquisition-date/basis report may therefore differ. Read the notice's conditions and the guidance for your transaction year before relying on an identification method.[4]
Invented example: average cost versus oldest unit
Buy one BTC for 30,000, buy another for 50,000, then sell one for 60,000. Assume no fees, no other holdings and both units in one wallet. These are invented amounts in one reporting currency to isolate the arithmetic, not a CAD-to-USD comparison or a tax estimate.
| Calculation | Cost of unit sold | Gain |
|---|---|---|
| Average cost: (30,000 + 50,000) / 2 | 40,000 | 20,000 |
| FIFO: oldest unit | 30,000 | 30,000 |
This example shows why the basis rule changes the gain. It does not establish eligibility for a method. BasisNorth pins this arithmetic to its calculation engine; it does not implement US wallet/account identification or holding-period reporting.
Retain the acquisition dates as well as the amounts
The IRS generally starts the holding-period count the day after acquisition and includes the disposal day. More than one year is long term; one year or less is short term.[5]
Keep the original lot history and wallet/account trail for review. Read the Canada–US reporting overview for the currency, inclusion and form differences.
Explore the calculations
Compare FIFO and LIFO in the free preview. Choose Canada for the paid Canadian ACB report. Read the reporting limits above before uploading.
Preview your CSVRelated guides
Sources
A calculation tool, not tax advice. This guide explains calculation concepts, not a filing position. Verify the rules for your tax year and review your figures with a qualified tax professional.